Why Do Most Rain Gutter Businesses Fail?

Top 5 reasons for failure


It's common for skilled gutter installers to see the next step in their career path as becoming a business owner. After gaining solid hands-on experience, they buy the essential equipment - a truck, a gutter machine, and some inventory - and start their own company. But, as straightforward as it may seem, running a successful gutter business isn't just about technical know-how and the right tools.

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that approximately 20% of (legally incorporated) small businesses close within their first year, and nearly 50% don't survive past five years. In the RGA's experience, most gutter companies fail within three years. This is a sobering reality for those who dream of turning their trade into a thriving business and for those looking for a reputable gutter contractor.

As a consumer or a gutter company owner, understanding the common reasons behind these failures can help you make better decisions. This article delves into the typical mistakes that gutter companies make and provides guidance on how to sidestep these pitfalls for lasting success.

1. Disregarding legal and tax protocols

When starting a gutter company, the excitement of owning a business and putting technical skills to work often takes the forefront. However, an equally crucial part lies in understanding and implementing appropriate business protocols.

A common mistake among new business owners is the misunderstanding the need for legal business setups. It's not uncommon to overlook the need to become a legal entity.Still, operating without this status can lead to a host of problems, including liability issues and potential fines. Mismanagement of employee hiring and payroll processes can also have legal repercussions and lead to employee dissatisfaction, which can negatively impact productivity and company reputation.

Let's break this down into three key areas that are often neglected - Taxes, Insurance, and Payroll Management.

Operating a business involves various tax obligations. Ignoring the responsibility to file taxes or incorrect filing can lead to hefty penalties, audits, and even legal proceedings. It's essential to understand your tax obligations, meet your deadlines, and keep accurate records.

In the gutter installation business, carrying adequate insurance is crucial. It covers potential property damage, employee accidents, and lawsuits. Operating without proper insurance, including health and worker's compensation, exposes your business to significant financial risks.

Payroll Management:
Payroll is more than just cutting checks. It includes managing deductions, such as taxes, social security, child support payments, and benefits.Neglecting these can lead to penalties and damage your relationship with employees.

Failing to adhere to these business protocols might not cause immediate problems, but it's a ticking time bomb that results in severe consequences down the line. For lasting success, a solid understanding of these areas is as important as the technical skills in gutter installation.

2. Neglecting systemization

Running a successful business goes beyond performing the core services well; it's about managing operations effectively. A lack of structured processes in the company can lead to inefficiencies, inconsistencies in service quality, and even operational breakdowns.

For example, one area often overlooked by new gutter company owners is fleet maintenance. If there's no system for maintaining work trucks - whether it's routine servicing, timely repairs, or safety inspections - the results can be catastrophic. A truck breaking down can lead to missed jobs, disappointed customers, and lost revenue.

Without a proper system, troubleshooting these issues can be chaotic and time-consuming. You might find yourself in a reactive state, continuously dealing with emergencies rather than preventing them (or, as they say, putting out fires).

The ultimate goal in any business is to be systemized and organized. This approach produces the same results (the results both you and the customer want) consistently.This requires a standard way of doing work.

A successful business is not just about the quality of services provided, but also about the effectiveness of its operations.

3. Failure to reinvest profits into the company (aka buying toys)

A major pitfall for many new business owners, not just those in the gutter industry, is the handling of initial profits. It's a significant milestone when your business begins to turn aprofit, and the temptation to spend this new income on personal luxuries (often, abrand-new truck or luxury vacation) can be strong. However, prioritizing these overreinvestment into the company hinders long-term growth and sustainability.

Here are a few areas where reinvestment can impact your business:

Upgrading or expanding your equipment can enhance your team's efficiency and the quality of your service. This could be a new, more efficient gutter machine, additional trucks to cover a larger service area, or even software for more effective job scheduling and tracking.

Employee Training and Benefits:
Your team is a vital part of your business. Offering training can improve their skills and productivity, enhancing the overall quality of your services. Attractive benefits can also help in retaining skilled workers.

Increased visibility brings in more customers and increases revenue. This often involves improving your website, investing in search engine optimization, or running online ad campaigns.

4. Undercharging for services

Setting the right prices for your services is a delicate balance. Price too high, and you risk losing customers to your competitors. Price too low, and you may not cover your costs or make a reasonable profit. Unfortunately, many new gutter companies fall into the trap of undercharging for their services, which can quickly lead to financial hardship.

There are two main issues that contribute to underpricing:

Disregarding Business Protocols: As discussed earlier, neglecting proper business protocols, like not understanding all your expenses or not paying appropriate taxes and insurance, can give a false perception of lower business costs. This misperception often leads to underpricing services. This always catches up, and once it does, can erase any semblance of profit you thought you had made and lead to bankruptcy.

Poor Understanding of Sales and Marketing: Lacking skills in sales and marketing can lead to undervaluing your services. Good sales skills help you negotiate the best prices for your services, while effective marketing can elevate your brand's perceived value, allowing you to charge accordingly.

Undercharging might bring in customers initially, but it's not a sustainable practice. It can lead to cash flow issues, hinder your ability to provide quality services, and ultimately, can cause your business to fail.

5. Over reliance on talent

Starting a business involves wearing multiple hats. But as your business grows, it's crucial to move from a one-person operation to a team-driven model. A common reason for failure among gutter companies is building the company around a single individual, usually either the owner or a particularly capable installer.

This over reliance leads to several problems:

Vulnerability to Absence: If the key person is unavailable due to illness, vacation, or any other reason, the business operations can be severely disrupted or even grind to a halt.

Lack of Scalability: A business that revolves around one person will always be limited by that person's capacity; once they've given 100%, there's no more left to give. This makes it impossible to scale operations.

Bottlenecks: If only one person has the knowledge or authority to perform certain tasks or make decisions, it creates bottlenecks. Tasks pile up waiting for that individual's attention, slowing down business operations.

Here’s the brutal truth: you can do everything right, but until you make yourself and your employees replaceable your business is doomed to fail. You cannot build a lasting enterprise around the talent of one person. 
As a consumer, selecting an RGA-certified company for your rain gutter needs ensures you're partnering with a business poised for longevity. When you see the RGA seal, you can trust that the company has undergone rigorous scrutiny to uphold high standards.

Working with an RGA-certified company provides peace of mind, knowing that your chosen provider is here to stay - and is charging a fair price. If you're an owner of a small rain gutter company, consider becoming an RGA member.

Our association provides an abundance of resources designed to help you circumvent the common pitfalls outlined in this article. As a member, you'll have access to:

Comprehensive training: Hone your skills and stay updated on industry developments.
Certifications: Gain recognition for your expertise and commitment to quality.
Valuable resources: Learn from a supportive community and access materials to help you manage and grow your business.
Benefits: Gain access to discounted services and insurance from RGA affiliates.

The Rain Gutter Association is committed to raising the bar in the rain gutter industry, benefiting consumers and businesses alike.
Created with